Registration is now open for SASE Week 2023! Get on the guest list.

  • Security Service Edge Products

    Protect against advanced and cloud-enabled threats and safeguard data across all vectors.

  • Borderless SD-WAN

    Confidently provide secure, high-performance access to every remote user, device, site, and cloud.

The platform of the future is Netskope

Intelligent Security Service Edge (SSE), Cloud Access Security Broker (CASB), Cloud Firewall, Next Generation Secure Web Gateway (SWG), and Private Access for ZTNA built natively into a single solution to help every business on its journey to Secure Access Service Edge (SASE) architecture.

Go to Products Overview
Netskope video
Borderless SD-WAN: Ushering in the New Era of Borderless Enterprise

Netskope Borderless SD-WAN offers an architecture that converges zero trust principles and assured application performance to provide unprecedented secure, high-performance connectivity for every site, cloud, remote user, and IoT device.

Read the article
Borderless SD-WAN
  • NewEdge

    NewEdge is the world’s largest, highest-performing security private cloud.

  • Cloud Security Platform

    Unrivaled visibility and real-time data and threat protection on the world's largest security private cloud.

  • Technology Partners & Integrations

    Netskope partners with the strongest companies in enterprise technology.

Embrace a Secure Access Service Edge (SASE) architecture

Netskope NewEdge is the world’s largest, highest-performing security private cloud and provides customers with unparalleled service coverage, performance and resilience.

Learn about NewEdge
NewEdge
Your Network of Tomorrow

Plan your path toward a faster, more secure, and more resilient network designed for the applications and users that you support.

Get the white paper
Your Network of Tomorrow
Netskope Cloud Exchange

The Netskope Cloud Exchange (CE) provides customers with powerful integration tools to leverage investments across their security posture.

Learn about Cloud Exchange
Netskope video
Make the move to market-leading cloud security services with minimal latency and high reliability.

Learn about NewEdge
Lighted highway through mountainside switchbacks
Safely enable the use of generative AI applications with application access control, real-time user coaching, and best-in-class data protection.

Learn how we secure generative AI use
Safely Enable ChatGPT and Generative AI
Zero trust solutions for SSE and SASE deployments

Learn about Zero Trust
Boat driving through open sea
Netskope enables a safe, cloud-smart, and fast journey to adopt cloud services, apps, and public cloud infrastructure.

Learn about Industry Solutions
Wind turbines along cliffside
  • Resources

    Learn more about how Netskope can help you secure your journey to the cloud.

  • Blog

    Learn how Netskope enables security and networking transformation through security service edge (SSE).

  • Events & Workshops

    Stay ahead of the latest security trends and connect with your peers.

  • Security Defined

    Everything you need to know in our cybersecurity encyclopedia.

Security Visionaries Podcast

Leveling Up the SASE Conversation
Robert Arandjelovic and Gerry Plaza sit down to chat with Max Havey about how embracing a SASE journey can help bring networking and security teams closer together.

Play the podcast
Leveling Up the SASE Conversation
Latest Blogs

How Netskope can enable the Zero Trust and SASE journey through security service edge (SSE) capabilities.

Read the blog
Sunrise and cloudy sky
SASE Week 2023: Your SASE journey starts now!

Join us for the fourth annual SASE Week, September 26-28.

Get on the guest list
SASE Week 2023
What is Security Service Edge?

Explore the security side of SASE, the future of network and protection in the cloud.

Learn about Security Service Edge
Four-way roundabout
  • Our Customers

    Netskope serves more than 2,000 customers worldwide including more than 25 of the Fortune 100

  • Customer Solutions

    We are here for you and with you every step of the way, ensuring your success with Netskope.

  • Netskope Community

    Learn from other network, data, and security professionals.

  • Training and Certification

    Netskope training will help you become a cloud security expert.

We help our customers to be Ready for Anything

See our Customers
Woman smiling with glasses looking out window
Netskope’s talented and experienced Professional Services team provides a prescriptive approach to your successful implementation.

Learn about Professional Services
Netskope Professional Services
The Netskope Community can help you and your team get more value out of products and practices.

Go to the Netskope Community
The Netskope Community
Secure your digital transformation journey and make the most of your cloud, web, and private applications with Netskope training.

Learn about Training and Certifications
Group of young professionals working
  • Company

    We help you stay ahead of cloud, data, and network security challenges.

  • Why Netskope

    Cloud transformation and work from anywhere have changed how security needs to work.

  • Leadership

    Our leadership team is fiercely committed to doing everything it takes to make our customers successful.

  • Partners

    We partner with security leaders to help you secure your journey to the cloud.

Supporting sustainability through data security

Netskope is proud to participate in Vision 2045: an initiative aimed to raise awareness on private industry’s role in sustainability.

Find out more
Supporting Sustainability Through Data Security
Highest in Execution. Furthest in Vision.

Netskope recognized as a Leader in the 2023 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Security Service Edge.

Get the report
Netskope recognized as a Leader in the 2023 Gartner® Magic Quadrant™ for Security Service Edge.
Thinkers, builders, dreamers, innovators. Together, we deliver cutting-edge cloud security solutions to help our customers protect their data and people.

Meet our team
Group of hikers scaling a snowy mountain
Netskope’s partner-centric go-to-market strategy enables our partners to maximize their growth and profitability while transforming enterprise security.

Learn about Netskope Partners
Group of diverse young professionals smiling

Leaving Bastion Hosts Behind Part 1: GCP

Jun 30 2020

Introduction

Any enterprise running virtual machines in the cloud needs to securely manage them, which is commonly done with Remote Desktop Protocol (RDP) or Secure Shell (SSH). One problem that arises is how to manage this access without exposing the management protocols to the internet, leaving them open to various types of attacks. Historically, it has been a best practice to implement bastion hosts to limit the exposure of the management protocols. However, there are some disadvantages to that approach. Recently, the big three cloud providers, Amazon Web Services (AWS), Google Cloud Platform (GCP), and Azure, have all released services that provide an alternative solution. We’ll be publishing a series of blog posts on these solutions, detailing the alternatives from each provider in its own blog post. The last blog post of the series will cover Netskope Private Access (NPA), which provides a Zero Trust Network Access (ZTNA) solution that is easy to deploy and can secure management access across all three providers.

In this post, we’ll first review what bastion hosts are, what the difficulties are with them, and then present the general model that all of the alternative solutions follow. Finally, we’ll examine the GCP services, OS Login, and Identity-Aware Proxy (IAP) in more detail to show how they can be used as an alternative to bastion hosts.

Bastion Hosts

Before looking at the alternatives, we will review what bastion hosts are and the general issues enterprises have with them.

What are bastion hosts?

Bastion hosts are computers that are deliberately exposed on a public network to enable access to a private network. Once a user has connected to the bastion host, they are able to access additional virtual machines that are not accessible from the internet. Because they are prone to attacks, bastion hosts should be appropriately hardened. These hosts should also be logging SSH sessions and sending the logs to a centralized repository.

Bastion hosts are usually hosted in separate subnets from the rest of your internal infrastructure, so the networks can be segmented. The bastion hosts are located within a publicly available subnet, while the more sensitive virtual machines are hosted in private subnets.

Why run bastion hosts?

Bastions provide security against brute force attacks on your sensitive virtual machines, by removing the need to open the SSH port to the internet. They allow an enterprise to consolidate access and reduce the attack surface of their infrastructure. Monitoring can also be consolidated and enhanced for sensitive workloads, so alerts attributed to bastions may be addressed faster than other alerts in the organization’s security monitoring tools.

Problems with Running Bastions

The problem with running bastion hosts is that it’s additional infrastructure you have to maintain yourself. Patching, monitoring, and keeping them running creates more load on your administrators. If you need to support a large user base, then you may need to run a lot of bastion hosts, and those all just add to your cloud provider bill.

In addition, there is a feature of SSH called SSH multiplexing, which may be used to attack your organization. It could allow a malicious actor to pivot from a user’s compromised laptop to your servers in the cloud. If you are able to use an alternative to bastion hosts, which we’ll discuss in more detail later in this post, then you can effectively eliminate the possibility of SSH multiplexing as a threat.

Another drawback of bastion hosts is that you must still manage the SSH keys. You may have a separate solution for this, but the use of bastions does not directly help with this problem.

General Overview of Alternatives

All three of the major cloud providers have created services that will give you an alternative to managing your own bastions, and, in some cases, they provide more than one alternative. This blog post series will not present all alternatives. It is focused on the alternatives that generally take the following approach:

  • Provide a cloud service that users will access with the cloud providers’ identity and access management (IAM) credentials.
  • Once authenticated, the cloud service typically creates an encrypted tunnel with port forwarding, which runs SSH or RDP for the user.

The benefits of this general approach include:

  • Public IP addresses are not required in order to access the virtual machines.
  • It eliminates the possibility of compromising an entire organization with SSH multiplexing attacks.
  • In some cases, disabling a user’s IAM credentials also removes SSH or RDP access.
  • Cloud audit logs will capture metadata for RDP or SSH sessions, and in some cases, full session logs are easy to collect through the provider’s service.

Presentation of the Alternatives

Since the implementation in each cloud provider is so different, we will break down information about each solution into the following categories:

  1. Networking Considerations
  2. Virtual Machine Configuration
  3. Identity Management
  4. Logging

GCP: OS Login and IAP

In GCP, there are two different services that provide functionality around access to your virtual machines (VMs). Using both together makes it very easy to decommission (or avoid creating) your own bastion hosts. The first service, OS Login, links SSH credentials to each Google identity. This allows GCP admins to easily manage access to VMs at either an instance or project level with IAM permissions. The second service, Identity-Aware Proxy (IAP), authenticates Google identities and can be configured to provide TCP forwarding for SSH or RDP access.

Networking Considerations

  • You must first enable IAP in the GCP project that contains the VMs you want the users to access. As with other services offered by GCP, the APIs are not enabled by default.
  • You must configure firewall rules to allow SSH or RDP traffic from the IAP address block, and apply that rule to the target VMs.

There is no need to assign Public IP addresses to the VMs, and the firewall rules don’t need to allow any traffic from the internet.

Virtual Machine Configuration

Users can apply permissions to allow connections from the IAP at the individual VM level (or it could be applied at a higher level). However, there are no other changes required to the VMs themselves to enable IAP.

In many cases, there are no VM changes required to use OS Login. However, there are two particular situations where additional changes may be required at the VM level:

  1. If custom images (that are not built upon a standard image from GCP) are being used for the VMs. In this case, you must install the Guest Environment.
  2. If the administrator of the GCP environment has not enabled OS Login at the project level. In this case, you must enable OS Login on each instance.

Identity Management

For OS Login, you must grant one of the following roles (or another role containing the same permissions) to users who should be able to access your VMs:

  • roles/compute.osLogin (for regular access)
  • roles/compute.osAdminLogin (for administrator level access)

Each user has the option of adding SSH keys to their identity for use with OS Login. However, if there is no key associated, GCP will generate ephemeral keys for the user. This is a great benefit, as you don’t have to implement a separate solution to manage SSH keys.

Once OS Login has been enabled, it’s very easy to enable Two-Factor Authentication (2FA) for SSH. If you already use GSuite, it can leverage the 2FA that’s already there, you just need to enable it in GCP. This can provide some great value for free if you are a GSuite customer.

For IAP, you must grant the following role (or another role that contains the same permissions) at the project or instance level: roles/iap.tunnelResourceAccessor. You may even specify the ports (such as port 22 for SSH) that the user is allowed to access on the VMs.

Logging

Without any additional configuration, the IAP service logs metadata about the SSH connection. The IAP authorization events for SSH tunneling are sent to the cloud audit logs in Stackdriver, so admins are able to browse these events right from the Stackdriver console, or wherever those logs are centralized. For users who are new to GCP and the logs, it may be a little difficult to find these events. There are generally two types of events generated by users in “cloudaudit” logs within GCP:

  • Admin Activity – Examples include where someone has created a resource or modified permissions.
  • Data Access – Examples include reading metadata or accessing data in object storage that requires authentication.

When attempting to tunnel into a VM with SSH, the IAP is requested to authorize the user. Information about this request, called “cloud.security.gatekeeper.AuthorizeUserRequest”, is actually sent to the Data Access logs. The log entries for these events provide a lot of useful information, including:

  • The primary email of the Google identity that made the request
  • The destination IP address and port (if no public IP is associated, you will see the RFC 1918 address)
  • The instance ID of the target VM
  • The IP address of the originating request
  • Timestamp of the authorization
  • If the authorization was granted or denied

Since these are only authorization events, you will not see any more details about the SSH session, such as what users did while they were connected, how many bytes were transferred, or when the session ended. If you require more of this type of information, you can install the Stackdriver agent on your VMs to send this information to Stackdriver. 

Conclusion

Using a combination of GCP’s OS Login and IAP will give you a very effective way to provide the protection of bastion hosts without having to manage much on your own. In particular, it provides the following advantages:

  • The target VMs do not require external IP addresses and are not required to allow any ingress traffic from the internet.
  • Since the SSH keys can be tied to a Google identity, you can avoid managing SSH keys manually.
  • It’s very easy to enable 2FA for SSH.
  • You are automatically provided simple information about who’s successfully accessing the VMs in the cloud audit logs.
  • The time to set this up in GCP is also very minimal, making it a great solution for organizations that may not have a lot of experience with GCP.

Some disadvantages include:

  • At the time of writing, OS Login is not supported by:
    • Google Kubernetes Engine (GKE) clusters
    • Fedora CoreOS images
    • Windows Server images
    • SQL Server images
  • It will take some additional effort to obtain granular details (such as a record of console commands) from the SSH sessions once a user has been authenticated.

If you are using VMs in GCP, we believe it would be worth your time to evaluate if OS Login and IAP will solve your access use cases before deploying your own bastion hosts.

author image
Colin Estep
Colin Estep has 16 years of experience in software, with 11 years focused on information security. He's currently a researcher at Netskope, where he focuses on security for AWS and GCP.

Stay informed!

Subscribe for the latest from the Netskope Blog